What Will Conservative Justices Mean For Business?

The U.S. Supreme Court’s fall term is sprinkled with business cases—none as momentous as the Obamacare lawsuit of 2012—but a useful window into how the court’s two newest justices will treat matters such as employment discrimination and environmental law.

The U.S. Supreme Court’s fall term is sprinkled with business cases—none as momentous as the Obamacare lawsuit of 2012—but a useful window into how the court’s two newest justices, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh, will treat matters such as employment discrimination and environmental law.

The good news for business is both justices are solid conservatives likely to join decisions limiting the scope of clean-water regulations and racial discrimination claims. The bad news is that like the other conservatives on the court, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh are likely to split with business on fundamental issues of law, including whether federal regulations preempt jury trials in state court.

The court’s conservatives may also split with big business on one of the highest-profile cases of the session: whether Title VII prohibiting employment discrimination on the basis of “sex” includes “gender.” Corporate America is in virtual lockstep in favor of the plaintiffs, with organizations from Altria Group to the American Independent Business Alliance saying a broader definition will make it easier to hire and retain gay and transgender employees.

Opponents are mostly religious organizations that believe Congress meant biological sex when it passed Title VII in 1964. Justice Gorsuch, as an appellate judge, joined a 2009 appellate decision allowing a transgender person to state a claim under Title VII, but he also voted in favor of Hobby Lobby’s religious rights in another decision that the Supreme Court upheld in 2014. Kavanaugh is known more for his work in administrative law than religion and could be a wild card on the definition of “sex.”

The court’s conservatives are more likely to deliver a victory for business in Comcast v. National Association of African American-Owned Media, in which a black-owned media company accuses the cable giant of engaging in a conspiracy with diverse characters, including Rev. Al Sharpton and the NAACP, to deny it carriage on Comcast’s systems. The oft-overturned Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals allowed the plaintiff’s case to proceed by dramatically loosening the standard for racial discrimination claims. The Supreme Court will probably overturn that decision, reinforcing the traditional legal requirement that plaintiffs show discrimination was a “but-for” cause—if not for the action, the result would not have happened—of a company’s decision, not merely one factor among many.

Comcast could represent “the new court majority’s push deeper into employment law as a way to tighten standards for proving discrimination,” said Thomas Saunders, an appellate partner with WilmerHale.

Business may also win big in County of Maui v. Hawaii Wildlife Fund, challenging another Ninth Circuit decision interpreting the Clean Water Act to govern the release of any pollutant that reaches groundwater that ultimately flows into “navigable waters” covered by the CWA. The Trump administration opposes the Ninth Circuit decision, which more closely aligns with the Obama administration’s expansive view of federal power to regulate the environment.

Justice Kavanaugh largely made his reputation by opposing regulatory overreach with decisions urging Congress to state more precisely what it wants federal administrative agencies to do. Lawmakers hate that, of course, since it’s easier to blame onerous regulations on unelected bureaucrats than themselves. But by reducing the scope of bureaucratic authority, the Supreme Court could make regulations more predictable.

“If you’re trying to make an investment decision but you don’t have a lot of certainty because the next election can flip the rule, you don’t have consistency,” says James Copland, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute. “Even a bad rule can be tolerable if you can price it into your products.”


MORE LIKE THIS

  • Get the CEO Briefing

    Sign up today to get weekly access to the latest issues affecting CEOs in every industry
  • upcoming events

    Roundtable

    Strategic Planning Workshop

    1:00 - 5:00 pm

    Over 70% of Executives Surveyed Agree: Many Strategic Planning Efforts Lack Systematic Approach Tips for Enhancing Your Strategic Planning Process

    Executives expressed frustration with their current strategic planning process. Issues include:

    1. Lack of systematic approach (70%)
    2. Laundry lists without prioritization (68%)
    3. Decisions based on personalities rather than facts and information (65%)

     

    Steve Rutan and Denise Harrison have put together an afternoon workshop that will provide the tools you need to address these concerns.  They have worked with hundreds of executives to develop a systematic approach that will enable your team to make better decisions during strategic planning.  Steve and Denise will walk you through exercises for prioritizing your lists and steps that will reset and reinvigorate your process.  This will be a hands-on workshop that will enable you to think about your business as you use the tools that are being presented.  If you are ready for a Strategic Planning tune-up, select this workshop in your registration form.  The additional fee of $695 will be added to your total.

    To sign up, select this option in your registration form. Additional fee of $695 will be added to your total.

    New York, NY: ​​​Chief Executive's Corporate Citizenship Awards 2017

    Women in Leadership Seminar and Peer Discussion

    2:00 - 5:00 pm

    Female leaders face the same issues all leaders do, but they often face additional challenges too. In this peer session, we will facilitate a discussion of best practices and how to overcome common barriers to help women leaders be more effective within and outside their organizations. 

    Limited space available.

    To sign up, select this option in your registration form. Additional fee of $495 will be added to your total.

    Golf Outing

    10:30 - 5:00 pm
    General’s Retreat at Hermitage Golf Course
    Sponsored by UBS

    General’s Retreat, built in 1986 with architect Gary Roger Baird, has been voted the “Best Golf Course in Nashville” and is a “must play” when visiting the Nashville, Tennessee area. With the beautiful setting along the Cumberland River, golfers of all capabilities will thoroughly enjoy the golf, scenery and hospitality.

    The golf outing fee includes transportation to and from the hotel, greens/cart fees, use of practice facilities, and boxed lunch. The bus will leave the hotel at 10:30 am for a noon shotgun start and return to the hotel after the cocktail reception following the completion of the round.

    To sign up, select this option in your registration form. Additional fee of $295 will be added to your total.