Great Companies are “Discovered, not Planned”, Research Suggests

Even the most creative leaders can be guilty of adopting a herd mentality.

Facebook, Uber and Lyft. None of those companies do today what they did when they were founded.

In fact, new research conducted by the University of Chicago and the Stanford Graduate School of Business suggests that leaders assuming they can stick with their prevailing vision, or follow the herd, often end up getting trampled.

The results have implications for even the most established companies as they face a constant need to re-invent themselves to cope with digital disruption.

“It’s almost always the case that the greatest firms are discovered and not planned,” Stanford professor William P. Barnett said.


To test their theory, Barnett and University of Chicago associate professor Elizabeth G. Pontikes examined the success rates of software companies operating in 4,566 organizations over 12 years. They discovered that leaders willing to adapt their initial ideas to find the right market were more likely to source financing and go public.

Leaders who adopted a “herd mentality” and chased perceived hot markets fared more poorly than those who defied common wisdom and explored markets that were recently tainted by failure. Among more established companies, Apple is a case in point: Steve Jobs continued to explore opportunities in the handset market to great success, even after the embarrassing failure of Apple’s Newton device in the early 1990s.

The study found that consensus behavior was also common among venture capitalists, though things soon turned awry for them, too. Companies could readily stump up some funding when entering a hot market, but were less viable, on average, and suffered from instability in their long-term market identities.

“Although non-consensus behavior may seem like foolishness at the time, it turns out out to be a wise alternative—if the organization can weather the heightened scrutiny,” the researchers concluded.

Ultimately, the inherent lesson for CEOs is that they must make staff feel comfortable about speaking up, even if that means offending their ears.

“They need to ask if the people who report to them are being quiet about their non-consensus ideas,” Barnett said. “If the answer is yes, then a leader has to wonder what that says about their leadership if people are afraid to suggest counterintuitive strategies.”

You might also like:
The CEO’s Role in Innovation
The Key to Successful Innovation Is Proper Implementation
5 Practical Lessons from Innovation Leaders You Can Apply Today
Mid-Market Companies are at the Frontier of Innovation
Here are the World’s Most Innovative CEOs, According to Tech Executives
Combining Strategy With Innovation Can Create a Competitive Advantage


  • Get the CEO Briefing

    Sign up today to get weekly access to the latest issues affecting CEOs in every industry
  • upcoming events