Close this search box.
Close this search box.

Some Boards can be too Independent, Research Says

The "home alone" CEO model may not be as effective as its cracked up to be, new research suggests.

Recent scandals including Wells Fargo’s bogus accounts fiasco have put the spotlight on board independence. But companies thinking they can ward off bad behavior by appointing fewer company insiders as directors could be making a big mistake.

Some 73% of companies in the S&P 1,500 currently boast of having their CEO as the only insider board member, up from 41% in 2000, according to researchers at Arizona State University.

The thinking is that these “home alone” CEOs will be able to bring adequate inside information to board meetings, allowing oversight to mostly be conducted at arms length by the independent directors.

The problem, the research found, is that these companies were 27% more likely to engage in financial misconduct. They also generated 10% lower net income, on average, than those with more than one inside director, while their top executives received much larger pay packets.

“It appears that lone-insider boards do not function as intended and firms should reconsider whether the push toward loan-insider boards is actually in shareholders’ best interests,” the researchers concluded in the paper, which is scheduled to appear in the Strategic Management Journal.

An issue facing lone-insider boards is that other directors will be reliant on inside information provided by only one person, who may or may not be as forthcoming about company workings as hoped.

Corroboration among other executives at board meetings could at least provide a check on CEO’s opinions, including on succession planning, the authors suggested.

In the wake of high-profile corporate collapses such as Enron, U.S. companies are now required by law to have a majority of independent directors.

Few studies, however, appear to show a direct link between board independence and strong company financial performance. To the contrary, a paper published back in 2000 by professors at the University of Colorado and Stanford Law School hinted that increased board independence could actually hurt a company’s financial performance.

“Inside directors are conflicted but well informed,” the authors concluded. “Independent directors are not conflicted, but are relatively ignorant about the company.”

They added: “Perhaps independent directors will be quicker to act if something goes wrong, but more likely, in their ignorance, to do the wrong thing, especially if their deliberations are not leavened by the information available to fellow inside directors.”


  • Get the CEO Briefing

    Sign up today to get weekly access to the latest issues affecting CEOs in every industry
  • upcoming events


    Strategic Planning Workshop

    1:00 - 5:00 pm

    Over 70% of Executives Surveyed Agree: Many Strategic Planning Efforts Lack Systematic Approach Tips for Enhancing Your Strategic Planning Process

    Executives expressed frustration with their current strategic planning process. Issues include:

    1. Lack of systematic approach (70%)
    2. Laundry lists without prioritization (68%)
    3. Decisions based on personalities rather than facts and information (65%)


    Steve Rutan and Denise Harrison have put together an afternoon workshop that will provide the tools you need to address these concerns.  They have worked with hundreds of executives to develop a systematic approach that will enable your team to make better decisions during strategic planning.  Steve and Denise will walk you through exercises for prioritizing your lists and steps that will reset and reinvigorate your process.  This will be a hands-on workshop that will enable you to think about your business as you use the tools that are being presented.  If you are ready for a Strategic Planning tune-up, select this workshop in your registration form.  The additional fee of $695 will be added to your total.

    To sign up, select this option in your registration form. Additional fee of $695 will be added to your total.

    New York, NY: ​​​Chief Executive's Corporate Citizenship Awards 2017

    Women in Leadership Seminar and Peer Discussion

    2:00 - 5:00 pm

    Female leaders face the same issues all leaders do, but they often face additional challenges too. In this peer session, we will facilitate a discussion of best practices and how to overcome common barriers to help women leaders be more effective within and outside their organizations. 

    Limited space available.

    To sign up, select this option in your registration form. Additional fee of $495 will be added to your total.

    Golf Outing

    10:30 - 5:00 pm
    General’s Retreat at Hermitage Golf Course
    Sponsored by UBS

    General’s Retreat, built in 1986 with architect Gary Roger Baird, has been voted the “Best Golf Course in Nashville” and is a “must play” when visiting the Nashville, Tennessee area. With the beautiful setting along the Cumberland River, golfers of all capabilities will thoroughly enjoy the golf, scenery and hospitality.

    The golf outing fee includes transportation to and from the hotel, greens/cart fees, use of practice facilities, and boxed lunch. The bus will leave the hotel at 10:30 am for a noon shotgun start and return to the hotel after the cocktail reception following the completion of the round.

    To sign up, select this option in your registration form. Additional fee of $295 will be added to your total.